← Back to blog
Return-to-Office PoliciesHybrid WorkingDisability DiscriminationReasonable AdjustmentsEquality Act 2010Occupational HealthWorkplace AssessmentsEmployee WellbeingHR AdviceEmployment LawWorkplace DisabilityFlexible Working

Is Your Return-to-Office Policy Creating a Disability Discrimination Risk?

Return Well

As employers tighten hybrid working arrangements, could a blanket approach to office attendance be creating legal risks they haven't fully considered?

The debate around working from home isn't going away.

Across the UK, employers are reviewing hybrid working arrangements, introducing minimum office attendance requirements and, in some cases, asking employees to return to the workplace full-time.

For many businesses, the reasons are understandable. Collaboration, communication, productivity and maintaining a workplace culture all matter.

But what happens when an employee says they cannot meet the new attendance requirements because of a health condition or disability?

And what if they've been performing their role successfully from home for several years?

This is where a seemingly straightforward workplace policy can become considerably more complicated.

One Policy Doesn't Necessarily Work for Everyone

Imagine an employer introduces a policy requiring everyone to attend the office three days a week.

Most employees comply without difficulty.

However, one employee has a chronic pain condition that makes commuting particularly difficult. Another is autistic and finds the sensory demands of a busy office overwhelming. A third experiences significant fatigue associated with a long-term health condition.

All three can perform their jobs effectively, but the new attendance requirements create additional barriers.

Should the same policy apply to everyone, regardless of their circumstances?

Under the Equality Act 2010, employers have a duty to make reasonable adjustments where a disabled employee would otherwise experience a substantial disadvantage.

Acas guidance explains that reasonable adjustments can include changes to working arrangements, including homeworking and hybrid working.

Importantly, treating everyone identically does not always mean treating everyone fairly.

Can Employers Still Require Office Attendance?

Yes.

Employers can have legitimate business reasons for requiring employees to attend the workplace. There may be genuine operational needs, including face-to-face collaboration, supervision, training or access to specialist equipment.

However, where an employee's disability affects their ability to comply, employers should consider their individual circumstances rather than automatically applying the same requirement.

Acas advises employers developing home and hybrid working policies to allow flexibility and consider requests outside their usual arrangements according to individual circumstances.

That doesn't mean every request to work from home must be agreed.

It means employers should explore the barriers, consider possible adjustments and assess what is reasonable in the circumstances. Depending on the situation, adjustments might include reduced office attendance, flexible start times, quieter working environments or alternative arrangements for particular duties.

he Risk of Making Assumptions

One of the challenges employers face is distinguishing between an employee's preference for homeworking and a disability-related need.

These aren't necessarily the same thing.

But neither should employers assume that someone requesting flexibility is simply reluctant to return to the office.

An employee may be managing a condition that isn't immediately visible. They may have developed effective coping strategies while working remotely, or their circumstances may have changed since they last attended regularly.

Equally, an employee may not yet have a formal diagnosis.

The absence of a diagnosis does not automatically mean there is no disability or that adjustments should not be considered.

Acas highlights that disabilities are not always obvious and that individuals with the same condition may experience very different workplace difficulties.

The important question is how the employee's circumstances affect their ability to work and what practical steps might reduce any disadvantage.

When an Independent Workplace Assessment Can Help

For employers, these conversations can be difficult to navigate, particularly where an employee and manager have different views about what is reasonable.

An independent workplace assessment can help establish a clearer understanding of the situation.

Rather than simply asking whether someone is fit to attend the office, an assessment can explore:

- How a health condition or disability affects the employee's work.

- Whether commuting or the workplace environment creates particular difficulties.

- Which adjustments might help the employee meet the requirements of their role.

- Whether alternative working arrangements could provide a practical solution.

- How proposed adjustments might be reviewed over time.

The aim isn't to automatically support either the employer's or employee's preferred outcome.

It's to provide objective, clinically informed recommendations that help both parties move forward.

Flexibility Isn't Always About Working From Home

It's also worth remembering that reasonable adjustments can take many forms.

For one employee, working from home more frequently may be appropriate.

For another, changes to lighting, noise levels, equipment, working hours or the physical workspace might make office attendance more manageable.

Acas recognises that reasonable adjustments are individual and can involve changes to the workplace, working patterns, equipment or support.

The most effective adjustments are often those developed through open discussion and a clear understanding of the individual's needs.

Before Enforcing Your Policy, Ask These Questions

Before taking formal action against an employee who cannot meet attendance requirements, employers should consider:

  • Do we understand why office attendance is difficult? There may be disability-related barriers that haven't yet been explored.

  • Have we considered reasonable adjustments? A standard policy doesn't remove the duty to consider individual circumstances.

  • Can we explain the business need? Employers should be clear about why particular duties require office attendance.

  • Would independent advice help? An assessment may identify practical adjustments that haven't previously been considered.

  • Have we documented our decision-making? Clear records can help demonstrate that individual circumstances were considered.

A More Considered Approach

Return-to-office policies are not inherently discriminatory.

But applying them rigidly without considering disability-related circumstances can create unnecessary risks, both legally and in terms of employee wellbeing.

Acas guidance makes clear that employers should consider individual needs when developing hybrid working arrangements and avoid discriminatory policies.

Sometimes, the most useful question isn't:

"Why won't this employee come into the office?"

It's:

"What's making office attendance difficult, and is there a practical way to address it?"

That change in perspective can make a significant difference.

How Return Well Can Help

At Return Well, we provide independent, clinician-led workplace assessments to help employers understand how health conditions and disabilities affect employees at work.

Our assessments provide practical, individualised recommendations on workplace adjustments, working arrangements and employee support.

We work with employers across the UK, offering remote assessments on a pay-per-case basis, without ongoing contracts.

Need independent advice about an employee's workplace needs?

Visit www.returnwell.co.uk to find out more or submit a referral.

References and Further Reading

Acas – What reasonable adjustments are

Explains employers' duties under the Equality Act 2010, including adjustments to working arrangements.

https://www.acas.org.uk/reasonable-adjustments

Acas – Home and hybrid working policies

Guidance on creating flexible policies that take account of employees' individual circumstances.

https://www.acas.org.uk/policies-for-home-and-hybrid-working/how-to-structure-a-policy

Acas – Supporting disabled people at work

Guidance on supporting employees with disabilities and avoiding discrimination.

https://www.acas.org.uk/supporting-disabled-people/how-an-employer-should-support-disabled-people

Acas – Requesting home or hybrid working

Explains flexible working requests and the separate right to request reasonable adjustments.

https://www.acas.org.uk/requests-for-home-and-hybrid-working

Disclaimer: This article is intended for general information and does not constitute legal advice. Employers should seek appropriate professional advice based on their individual circumstances.

Submit a Case